Line 15: Line 15:
  
 
Now, consider 2,2,4. If it has to hold then,  
 
Now, consider 2,2,4. If it has to hold then,  
a * a = e
+
a * a = e
b * b = e and
+
b * b = e and
c * c = a
+
c * c = a
=> a * c = b and
+
=> a * c = b and
b * c = e (to get $c^4 = e$)
+
b * c = e (to get $c^4 = e$)
 
But then, the associativity property of  
 
But then, the associativity property of  
 
  [(a * c) * b] = [a * (c * b)]  
 
  [(a * c) * b] = [a * (c * b)]  

Revision as of 14:01, 14 April 2014

Let <math>G\{e,a,b,c\}</math> be an abelian group with <math>'e'</math> as an identity element. The order of the other elements are:

(A) 2,2,3

(B) 3,3,3

(C) 2,2,4

(D) 2,4,4

Solution

Abelian_group

As a consequence of Lagrange's theorem, the order of every element of a group divides the order of the group. Hence, 3 cannot be the order of any element in the group.

Now, consider 2,2,4. If it has to hold then, a * a = e b * b = e and c * c = a => a * c = b and b * c = e (to get $c^4 = e$) But then, the associativity property of

[(a * c) * b] = [a * (c * b)] 

fails as (a * c) * b = e and a * (c * b) = a. Hence, 2,2,4 is not the answer.

* e a b c
e e a b c
a a e c b
b b c a e
c c b e a
a * a = e => order(a) = 2
b * b * b * b = a * b * b = c * b = e => order(b) = 4
c * c * c * c = a * c * c = b * c = e => order(c) = 4

So, the answer is 2,4,4. (2,2,2 is another possibility)



blog comments powered by Disqus

Let <math>G\{e,a,b,c\}</math> be an abelian group with <math>'e'</math> as an identity element. The order of the other elements are:

(A) 2,2,3

(B) 3,3,3

(C) 2,2,4

(D) 2,4,4

Solution[edit]

Abelian_group

As a consequence of Lagrange's theorem, the order of every element of a group divides the order of the group. Hence, 3 cannot be the order of any element in the group.

Now, consider 2,2,4. If it has to hold then, a * a = e b * b = e and c * c = a => a * c = b and b * c = e (to get $c^4 = e$) But then, the associativity property of

[(a * c) * b] = [a * (c * b)] 

fails as (a * c) * b = e and a * (c * b) = a. Hence, 2,2,4 is not the answer.

* e a b c
e e a b c
a a e c b
b b c a e
c c b e a
a * a = e => order(a) = 2
b * b * b * b = a * b * b = c * b = e => order(b) = 4
c * c * c * c = a * c * c = b * c = e => order(c) = 4

So, the answer is 2,4,4. (2,2,2 is another possibility)



blog comments powered by Disqus